Clinical outcomes of laparoscopic hepatectomy and open hepatectomy for hepatocellular carcinoma: A meta-analysis
-
摘要:
目的系统评价腹腔镜与开腹手术治疗肝细胞癌的近远期疗效及安全性。方法计算机检索有关腹腔镜与开腹手术治疗肝细胞癌的随机对照试验及临床对照试验的所有英文文献,并采用Cochrane协作网专用软件RevMan 5.1对数据进行统计分析,采用比值比(OR)及其95%可信区间(95%CI)和加权均数(WMD)及其95%CI对结果进行分析。结果未获得随机对照实验,12个病例对照实验被纳入,合计980例患者,其中391例行腹腔镜,589例行开腹手术。Meta分析结果显示:(1)手术时间:两组差异无统计学意义(WMD=3.34,95%CI:-19.17~25.85,P=0.77);(2)术中输血率:腹腔镜组低于开腹手术组,差异有统计学意义(OR=0.48,95%CI:0.26~0.89,P=0.02);(3)术后住院天数:腹腔镜组短于开腹手术组,差异有统计学意义(WMD=-4.27,95%CI:-6.18~-2.37,P<0.0001);(4)术中出血量:腹腔镜组低于开腹手术组,差异有统计学意义(WMD=-242.5,95%CI:-458.67~-26.34,P=0.03);(5)术后并发症发生率...
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the short-and long-term efficacy and safety of laparoscopic hepatectomy (LH) and open hepatectomy (OH) treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) using a systematic and comprehensive analysis of published cases.Methods Randomized controlled trials and case-control trials of LH and OH in HCC patients were retrieved from the public literature databases.Meta-analysis was carried out with the RevMan 5.1 software.Treatment effects were measured by calculating the odds ratio (OR) or the weighted mean difference (WMD) , with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) .Results Twelve studies were included in the analysis, and represented 980 patients (LH, n=391;OH, n=589) .The LH and OH operative times were not significantly different (WMD=3.34, 95%CI:-19.17, 25.85, P=0.77) .However, the LH group had significantly fewer blood transfusions (OR=0.48, 95%CI:0.26, 0.89, P=0.02) , shorter hospital stay (WMD=-4.27, 95%CI:-6.18, -2.37, P<0.0001) , less intraoperative blood loss (WMD=-242.5, 95%CI:-458.67, -26.34, P=0.03) , and less complications (OR=0.48, 95%CI:0.31, 0.75, P=0.001) .The surgery margin was similar between the two procedures (LH vs.OH: WMD=0.76, 95%CI:-0.03, 1.56, P=0.06) .There were significant differences in outcomes between the two treatment groups.While the LH group had a significantly lower mortality (OR=0.24, 95%CI:0.07, 0.86, P=0.03) , there were no significant differences in the disease-free survival rates until the 5-year follow-up when the LH group showed a higher rate (OR=1.61, 95%CI:1.18, 2.19, P=0.003) .Conclusion Laparoscopy is a minimally invasive procedure, compared to open surgical resection.Laparoscopic resection of liver cancer results in less trauma, quicker recovery, less intraoperative blood loss, and fewer postoperative complications, and should be considered as the preferred treatment option for patients amenable to surgery.
-
Key words:
- liver neoplasms /
- laparoscopy /
- surgical procedures /
- operative
-
临床上,胰腺恶性肿瘤大部分为原发肿瘤,胰腺转移癌少见[1]。胰腺转移癌与胰腺原发肿瘤鉴别困难,极易造成误诊,延误治疗。目前,胰腺转移癌国内外尚无统一治疗标准,原发肿瘤的生物学特性和针对原发肿瘤的综合治疗是决定其预后的主要因素,个体化差异较大。近期,笔者接诊1例宫颈鳞癌胰腺转移患者,现将病例资料及经验总结报告如下。
1. 病例资料
患者女性,63岁,因“皮肤、巩膜黄染20余天”于2021年3月27日入本院。起初黄染程度不重,后进行性加重,无腹痛腹胀,无阴道流血等其他不适。曾于2013年9月6日因阴道异常流血于外院行宫颈活检,病理学诊断为宫颈中分化鳞癌ⅢB期,予局部放疗联合TP方案(多西他赛+奥沙利铂)化疗,于2015年结束治疗后复查腹盆腔脏器、腹腔、盆腔均未见肿瘤转移。出院后患者再未复查,亦无特殊不适。入院查体:皮肤巩膜明显黄染,腹平坦,腹部无压痛,腹部未触及肿块。辅助检查:TBil 282.99 μmol/L,DBil 203.80 μmol/L,CA19-9正常;妇科彩超示:老年性子宫;全腹盆腔增强CT示:肝内外胆管扩张,主胰管可见(图 1a),胆囊明显增大,胆总管下段狭窄,动脉期见胰腺钩突区低密度肿块(图 1b),静脉期肿块轻度强化(图 1c),子宫显示不明显,腹膜后可见多发淋巴结肿大;磁共振胰胆管造影示:胰头区异常信号肿块,肝内外胆管扩张,胆汁淤积;超声内镜示:胰头钩突区占位,直径约3 cm。入院后予以护肝利胆治疗,患者黄疸进行性加重,建议患者行穿刺活检、PET-CT检查,患方拒绝。2021年4月4日行剖腹探查:术中探查发现肿瘤位于胰头钩突区,质地硬,侵犯十二指肠壁和胆总管,腹膜后见多发淋巴结肿大,行胰头十二指肠切除术。术后病理学检查结果:胰腺钩突肿块大小3.0 cm×2.0 cm×1.5 cm,癌组织侵犯十二指肠及胆总管,胰腺切缘未见癌。癌组织呈团块状或条索状癌巢(图 2a),癌细胞及核大小、形态不一,分布不规则,核分裂像多见,癌组织侵犯淋巴管及血管,脉管内见癌栓(图 2b),周围淋巴结可见癌转移(2/2)。免疫组化:P16(弥漫性+),P63(+),P40(+),CK7(+),CK8(+),CK19(+),ER(+)(图 2c、d)。诊断考虑胰腺钩突区中分化鳞状细胞癌,结合临床病史及免疫组化结果,考虑宫颈鳞癌转移。目前,该患者于本院进一步针对原发肿瘤行化疗等综合治疗,日常生活行为已恢复正常。
2. 讨论
据统计,宫颈癌的患病/病死率在女性恶性肿瘤中居第4位,鳞状细胞癌是最常见的病理类型,占比约80%,P16、P40等表达阳性对宫颈鳞癌诊断有重要意义。宫颈鳞癌早期往往无特殊表现,晚期可出现异常阴道流血、腰痛、盆腔痛、性交痛、贫血等表现,诊断时大多发生转移,多转移至直肠、膀胱、盆腔、肺、骨、肝等。临床上,胰腺癌多为原发肿瘤,胰腺转移癌罕见,仅占胰腺恶性肿瘤总数的2%~3%[2]。在一项纳入973例胰腺肿瘤手术标本病理资料的研究[3]中,共38例为胰腺转移瘤,主要包括淋巴瘤11例,胃癌7例,肾癌6例,肺癌2例,肝癌、前列腺癌、卵巢癌、子宫癌各1例,默克尔细胞癌1例,另有3例胃肠道恶性间质瘤和1例腹膜后平滑肌肉瘤;81例转移性胰腺肿瘤尸检报告显示,主要来源肺癌34例,胃肠道20例,肾脏4例,乳腺3例,肝脏2例,卵巢和膀胱各1例,另有6例来自造血系统,黑色素瘤、肉瘤和间皮瘤各2例。来源于宫颈的胰腺转移癌并不多见,笔者在国内外文献检索系统中,共检出各类型宫颈癌胰腺转移病例报告10例[4-7],其中鳞癌3例,神经内分泌癌5例,腺癌2例;转移灶位于胰头3例,位于颈部1例,位于胰腺体部3例,位于尾部、体尾部和胰头及体尾部各1例。转移灶位于胰头的3例患者中,1例为鳞癌,2例为神经内分泌癌,胰腺转移部位与宫颈癌病理类型无明显关联。本例患者在宫颈鳞癌同步放化疗后再未复查,6年后转移至胰腺钩突,临床表现为梗阻性黄疸,行胰头十二指肠切除术,术后病理学检查考虑鳞癌,结合免疫组化考虑为宫颈癌来源。目前,国内尚未见类似报道,国外也鲜有相关报道。
原发性胰腺癌与胰腺转移癌鉴别需依赖血清CA19-9水平、CT、MRI、磁共振胰胆管造影、内镜逆行胰胆管造影、超声内镜等检查手段。本例患者CT和MRI特点较原发性胰腺癌无特异表现,鉴别困难。血清CA19-9水平升高常见于胆道、胰腺恶性肿瘤,对诊断原发性胰腺癌有较高的敏感度和特异度[8]。鉴别困难时,可采用通过超声、CT及内镜引导下穿刺活检获取胰腺组织学、细胞学标本进行确诊,但需要评估穿刺活检的出血风险[9]。一般认为,超声内镜经十二指肠细针穿刺抽吸活检可提高胰腺疾病诊断的准确性,且相对安全[10-11]。本例患者术前影像学检查提示胰头钩突区占位,CA19-9水平不高,且有宫颈鳞癌病史,建议进一步行穿刺活检、PET-CT检查。但患者存在梗阻性黄疸,肝功能持续恶化,有手术指征,且患者家属不同意术前行穿刺活检、PET-CT等进一步检查,因此术前未能获得病理学诊断。
转移性胰腺癌临床表现因胰腺转移部位不同而异。在笔者检出的10例报告中,仅有1例(鳞癌)出现梗阻性黄疸,提示宫颈癌胰腺转移鲜有梗阻性黄疸症状,部分病例可因肿瘤压迫出现胆胰管扩张。转移性胰腺癌出现胰胆管梗阻较少见,可能与原发肿瘤主要经过淋巴及血行途径转移侵犯胰腺,不侵犯胆胰管有关[12]。本例患者胰腺转移性肿瘤致梗阻性黄疸,目前国内尚未见类似报道,国外仅有1例类似报道,但未分析相关转移机制。本例患者影像学检查示肝、胃、肠道等器官均未见肿瘤,但有腹膜后淋巴结肿大,病理学检查阳性;在既往10例报告中,3例胰腺转移性宫颈鳞癌有2例伴腹膜后淋巴结肿大,因此笔者推测宫颈鳞癌胰腺转移可能与腹膜后淋巴结侵犯相关。
关于转移性胰腺癌是否需要手术,意见尚未统一。以急腹症、进行性黄疸、出血为临床表现患者,应行急诊手术治疗,解除症状同时,切除病灶送检,根据病理学检查结果制订综合治疗方案。研究[13-14]表明,转移性胰腺癌行手术切除相较于保守治疗可延长生存期,且根治性手术相较于姑息性手术,预后更好。术后根据原发病灶辅以化疗等综合治疗,可提高治疗效果。对无法接受手术的转移性胰腺癌患者,应根据原发肿瘤的生物学特性制订以放疗为主的个体化综合治疗方案[15]。本例患者影像学检查提示存在胆道梗阻,并见胰头钩突区占位;胆红素水平持续升高,手术指征明确,手术切除胰腺钩突病灶、解除胆道梗阻后,胆红素水平明显下降,目前患者恢复良好,进一步接受化疗等综合治疗,延长生存期。
笔者经验总结:(1)对于诊断不明确的胰腺肿瘤,术前条件允许情况下需行穿刺活检明确性质,以指导下一步治疗方案;(2)胰腺转移癌在具备手术条件情况下,应积极采取以根治性手术为主的治疗方案,姑息性切除方案亦可行。胰腺转移癌为晚期癌症,术后需早期予以放化疗、靶向、免疫治疗等综合治疗;(3)对于不具备手术条件的患者,需根据原发肿瘤予以抗肿瘤综合治疗,包括放疗、化疗以及免疫治疗、靶向治疗等[16-17]。
-
[1]Llovet JM, Burroughs A, Bruix J.Hepatocellular carcinoma[J].Lancet, 2003, 362 (9399) :1907-1917. [2] Parkin DM, Bray F, Ferlay J, et al.Global cancer statistics, 2002[J].CA Cancer J Clin, 2005, 55 (2) :74-108. [3]Venook AP, Papandreou C, Furuse J, et al.The incidence and epide-miology of hepatocellular carcinoma:a global and regional perspective[J].Oncologist, 2010, 15 (Suppl 4) :5-13. [4]Mazzaferro V, Chun YS, Poon RT, et al.Liver transplantation forhepatocellular carcinoma[J].Ann Surg Oncol, 2008, 15 (4) :1001-1007. [5]Laurent A, Cherqui D, Lesurtel M, et al.Laparoscopic liver resec-tion for subcapsular hepatocellular carcinoma complicating chronicliver disease[J].Arch Surg, 2003, 138 (7) :763-769. [6]Nguyen KT, Gamblin TC, Geller DA.World review of lapa roscop-ic liver resection 2, 804 patients[J].Ann Surg, 2009, 250 (5) :831-841. [7]Hu BS, Chen K, Tan HM, et al.Comparison of laparoscopic vs openliver lobectomy (segmentectomy) for hepatocellular carcinoma[J].World J Gastroenterol, 2011, 17 (42) :4725-4728. [8]Shimada M, Hashizume M, Maehara S, et al.Laparoscopic hepa-tectomy for hepatocellular carcinoma[J].Surg Endosc, 2001, 15 (6) :541-544. [9]Lai EC, Tang CN, Ha JP, et al.Laparoscopic liver resection forhepatocellular carcinoma:ten-year experience in a single center[J].Arch Surg, 2009, 144 (2) :143-147. [10]Sarpel U, Hefti MM, Wisnievsky JP, et al.Outcome for patientstreated with laparoscopic versus open esection of hepatocellular car-cinoma:case-matched analysis[J].Ann Surg Oncol, 2009, 16 (6) :1572-1577. [11]Aldrighetti L, Guzzetti E, Pulitano C, et al.Case-matched analy-sis of totally laparoscopic versus open liver resection for HCC:shortand middle term results[J].J Surg Oncol, 2010, 102 (1) :82-86. [12]Tranchart H, Di Giuro G, Lainas P, et al.Laparoscopic resection forhepatocellular carcinoma:a matched-pair comparative study[J].SurgEndosc, 2010, 24 (5) :1170-1176. [13]Nguyen KT, Marsh JW, Tsung A, et al.Comparative benefits oflaparoscopic vs open hepatic resection:a critical appraisal[J].Arch Surg, 2011, 146 (3) :348-356. [14]Lee KF, Chong C N, Wong J, et al.Long-Term Results of Lapa-roscopic Hepatectomy Versus Open Hepatectomy for HepatocellularCarcinoma:A Case-Matched Analysis[J].World J Surg, 2011, 35 (10) :2268-2274. [15]Kim HH, Park EK, Seoung JS, et al.Liver resection for hepatocel-lular carcinoma:case-matched analysis of laparoscopic versus openresection[J].Korean Surg Soc, 2011, 80 (6) :412-419. [16]Ker CG, Chen JS, Kuo KK, et al.Liver Surgery for HepatocellularCarcinoma:Laparoscopic versus Open Approach[J].Int J Hepatol, 2011, 2011:596792. [17]Truant S, Bouras AF, Hebbar M, et al.Laparoscopic resection vs.open liver resection for peripheral hepatocellular carcinoma in patientswith chronic liver disease:a case-matched study[J].Surg Endosc, 2011, 25 (11) :3668-3677. [18]Wells GA, Shea B, O’Connell D, et al.The Newcastle-OttawaScale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomized studies inmeta-analyses[J].The Ottawa Health Research Institute, 2010. [19]Athanasiou T, Al-Ruzzeh S, Kumar P, et al.Off-pump myocar-dial revascularization is associated with less incidence of stroke inelderly patients[J].Ann Thorac Surg, 2004, 77 (2) :745-753. [20]Mathurin P, Raynard B, Dharancy S, et al.Meta-analysis:eval-uation of adjuvant therapy after curative liver resection for hepatocel-lular carcinoma[J].Aliment Pharmacol Ther, 2003, 17 (10) :1247-1261. [21]Novitsky YW, Litwin DE, Callery MP.The net immunologic advan-tage of laparoscopic surgery[J].Surg Endosc, 2004, 18 (10) :1411-1419. [22]张绍庚, 魏炜明, 陈永标, 等.腹腔镜肝切除30例[J].消化外科, 2005, 4 (2) :87-89. [23]Cherqui D, Laurcnt A, Tayer C, et al.Laparoscopic liver resectionfor peripheral hepatnoelinlar carcinoma in patients with chrooic liverdisease:midterra results and perspectives[J].Aan Surf, 2006, 243 (4) :499-506. [24]Suh KS, Yi NJ, Kim J, et al.Laparoscopic hepatectomy for a modifiedright graft in adult-to-adult living donor liver transplantation[J].Transplant Proc, 2008, 40 (10) :3529-3231. [25]Coelho JC, Freitas AC, Mathias JE.Laparoscopic resection of the leftlateral segment of the liver in living donor liver transplantation[J].RevCol Bras Cir, 2009, 36 (6) :537-538. [26]Baker TB, Jay CL, Ladner DP, et al.Laparoscopy-assisted anopen living donor right hepatectomy:a comparative study of out-comes[J].Surgery, 2009, 146 (4) :817-823. [27]Belli G, Fantini C, D'Agostino A, et al.Laparoscopic versus openliver resection for hepatocellular carcinoma in patients with histologi-cally proven cirrhosis:short-and middle-term results[J].SurgEndosc, 2007, 21 (11) :2004-2011. [28]Buell JF, Cherqui D, Geller DA, et al.The international positionon laparoscopic liver surgery:The Louisville Statement, 2008[J].Ann Surg, 2009, 250 (5) :825-830. [29]Ito K, Ito H, Are C, et al.Laparoscopic versus open liver resec-tion:a matched-pair case control study[J].J Gastrointest Surg, 2009, 13 (12) :2276-2283. [30]Cai XJ, Yang J, Yu H, et al.Clinical study of laparoscopic versusopen hepatectomy for malignant liver tumors[J].Surg Endosc, 2008, 22 (11) :2350-2356. [31]Endo Y, Ohta M, Sasaki A, et al.Acomparative study of the long-term outcomes after aparoscopy-assisted and open left lateral hepatec-tomy for hepatocellular carcinoma[J].Surg Laparosc Endosc PercutanTech, 2009, 19 (5) :e171-174. [32]Topal B, Fieuws S, Aerts R, et al.Laparoscopic versus open liverresection of hepatic neoplasms:comparative analysis of short-termresults[J].Surg Endosc, 2008, 22 (10) :2208-2213. [33]Gagner M, Rogula T, Selzer D.Laparoscopic liver resection:bene-fits and controversies[J].Surg Clin North Am, 2004, 84 (2) :451-462. [34]Li N, Wu YR, WuB, et al.Surgical and oncologic outcomes fol-lowing laparoscopic versus open liver resection for hepatocellularcarcinoma:A meta-analysis[J].Hepatol Res, 2012, 42 (1) :51-59. [35]郑树国, 李建伟, 李剑斌, 等.腹腔镜肝切除术的初步经验[J].消化外科, 2007, 6 (6) :424-427. [36]Biertho L, Waage A, Gagner M.Laparoscopic hepatectomy[J].Ann Clair, 2002, 127 (3) :164-170. [37]Kaneko H, Takagi S, Otsuka Y, et al.Laparoscopic liver resectionof hepatocellular carcinoma[J].Am J Surg, 2005, 189 (2) :190-194. [38]Chen HY, Juan CC, Ker CG.Laparoscopic liver surgery for pa-tients with hepatocellular carcinoma[J].Ann Surg Oncol, 2008, 15 (3) :800-806. [39]Dagher I, Lainas P, Carloni A, et al.Laparoscopic liver resectionfor hepatocellular carcinoma[J].Surg Endosc, 2008, 22 (2) :372-378. [40]Cherqui D, Laurent A, Tayar C, et al.Laparoscopic liver resectionfor peripheral hepatocellular carcinoma in patients with chronic liverdisease:midterm results and perspectives[J].Ann Surg, 2006, 243 (4) :499-506. [41]Belli G, Fantini C, D'Agostino A, et al.Laparoscopic liver resec-tions for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in cirrhotic patients[J].HPB (Oxford) , 2004, 6 (4) :236-246. [42]Abraham NS, Byrne CJ, Young JM, et al.Meta-analysis of well-designed nonrandomized comparative studies of surgical proce-dures is as good as randomized controlled trials[J].J Clin Epidemi-ol, 2010, 63 (3) :238-245. 期刊类型引用(1)
1. 李帅,王娟,夏仕雪,顾鹏. 子宫颈混合性腺神经内分泌癌胰腺转移1例. 中国医学影像学杂志. 2022(12): 1283-1284 . 百度学术
其他类型引用(0)
-